Debtors vs Borrowers: Definition, Legal Rights, Credit Scoring and Debt Collection

Who are Debtors and Borrowers?

Debtors and borrowers are individuals or entities who take on a debt or loan, respectively, and are obligated to repay it, sometimes providing collateral under secured transactions law.

Debtors and borrowers are essentially the same, both referring to individuals or entities who owe money to another party, with the term “borrower” specifically used in the context of a loan transaction.

Debtors and Borrowers Legal Definition

The main difference between debtors vs borrowers is that a debtor owes money to a creditor, while a borrower receives money from a lender with the promise and intention of paying it back.

When it comes to finances, these two terms that are often used interchangeably but have distinct meanings.

While they both involve exchanging money, there are important differences between the concepts that individuals and businesses should understand.

Who is a Debtor?

A debtor is an individual, business, or organisation that owes money to another party. In other words, a debtor is a person or entity that has received goods or services on credit or borrowed money and must pay it back.

The creditor, in this case, is the individual or organization that provided the goods or services or loaned the money.

Debtors can result from different circumstances, including taking out a car loan, using a credit card for purchases, or borrowing money from a financial institution.

The debtor is responsible for repaying the borrowed funds and any interest or fees accrued per legal obligation.

Who is a Borrower?

A borrower, on the other hand, is a person or organisation that receives money from another party with the intention of paying it back.

Unlike a debtor, a borrower does not necessarily owe money to the lender when the funds are received. Instead, the borrower is expected to use the funds to invest, start a business, or make a large purchase, among other reasons.

When one borrows money, a formal agreement is typically established between the borrower and lender, which outlines the borrowing terms, including the amount borrowed, interest rate, repayment period, and other conditions.

The borrower is then responsible for making regular payments, often on a monthly basis, until the loan is fully repaid.

Read post: Secured Creditor vs Unsecured Creditor

Obligations of Debtors and Borrowers

The obligations of debtors and borrowers differ significantly. Debtors are legally obligated to repay the funds they owe to the creditor.

If a debtor fails to repay the debt, the creditor has the right to take legal action to recover the funds, such as through wage garnishment or seizing assets.

On the other hand, borrowers are expected to make regular payments on the loan as outlined in the agreement. Failure to do so can result in penalties, such as late fees or increased interest rates.

However, a borrower’s failure to repay a loan does not automatically give the lender the right to seize assets or take legal action.

Instead, the lender may report the delinquency to credit reporting agencies, which can negatively impact the borrower’s credit score and ability to obtain credit in the future.

Read post: Personal Insolvency vs Corporate Insolvency: Legal Framework, Implications and Rescue

Legal Implications: Debtors vs Borrowers

The legal implications of debtor and borrower relationships are also different. When a debtor fails to repay a debt, the creditor can take legal action to recover the funds owed.

Depending on the nature of the debt, this may include wage garnishment, seizure of assets, or other legal actions.

In contrast, the legal implications of a borrower’s failure to repay a loan are usually limited to penalties and damage to the borrower’s credit score.

While lenders have the right to take legal action to recover funds owed, they generally do so as a last resort and only after other options have been exhausted – see Illingworth v Houldsworth (1904).

The Main Differences Between a Debtor and a Borrower:

When a person or entity borrows money (i.e., is a borrower), their credit score can be affected in both positive and negative ways.

If a borrower makes payments on time and in full, it can improve their credit score. This is because credit bureaus view borrowers who make timely payments as more creditworthy.

On the other hand, if a borrower misses payments or default on repayment, their credit score will likely be negatively impacted.

Additionally, too much debt can negatively impact a borrower’s credit score, as credit bureaus view borrowers who are heavily indebted as riskier – see Re Spectrum Plus Ltd (In Liquidation) (2005).

Read article: UCC 3-603 (Tender of Payment) Explained

Here are some examples of legal rights that debtors in the UK have:

• Protection from harassment: Debtors and borrowers have the right to be free from harassment or intimidation by creditors or debt collectors. This means that debt collectors cannot engage in activities such as threatening to harm the debtor or borrower or their property, using obscene or profane language, or repeatedly calling the debtor all day and night.

• Fair treatment: Debtors and borrowers have the right to be treated fairly by creditors or lenders. This means that creditors or lenders must not discriminate against debtors based on their race, gender, age, or other protected characteristics.

• Time to pay: Debtors and borrowers can ask for time to pay if they cannot. Creditors and lenders must consider a debtor’s request for time to pay and provide reasonable time for the debtor to pay their debts.

• Accurate reporting: Debtors have the right to report their debts on their credit reports accurately. Creditors must provide accurate information to credit bureaus, and if a debtor believes that the information on their credit report is inaccurate, they have the right to dispute it.

Fair Debt Collection Practices in the UK

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) regulates debt collection practices in the UK and has rules to ensure that debt collectors treat debtors fairly.

The FCA requires debt collectors to be clear and transparent in their communications with debtors and prohibits them from engaging in unfair or misleading practices.

The Consumer Rights Act 2015, Consumer Protection Act 1987 and Consumer Credit Act 1974 regulate consumer unfair practices, including those that affect debtors and borrowers.

Read post: Fixed Charge vs Floating Charge: Legal Definition, Attachment, Crystallization

Fair Debt Collection Practices in the US

Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA): The FDCPA is a federal law that outlines specific rules and regulations that debt collectors must follow when attempting to collect a debt from a debtor. The law prohibits abusive, deceptive, or unfair debt collection practices.

Final Thoughts: Debtors vs Borrowers

The main difference between a debtor and a borrower is that a debtor owes money to a creditor. In contrast, a borrower receives money from a lender with the intention of paying it back.

Debtors are legally obligated to repay their debts, while borrowers are expected to make regular payments on the loan as outlined in the agreement.

Failure to repay debt can have serious legal implications for debtors, while borrowers may face penalties and damage to their credit score.

It is important for individuals and businesses to understand the difference between debtor and borrower and their respective obligations.

By doing so, they can make informed decisions about borrowing and lending money and avoid legal and financial problems down the road.

Read posts:
Debenture: Legal Definition
Forfaiting vs Factoring
Invoice Discounting vs Invoice Factoring
UCP 600 Legal Definition